A field guide to narrative construction

Framecheck

Thirty-two recurring ways an article, a headline, or a fact-check can be built entirely from true statements and still leave you believing something false. This isn't a truth detector — nothing here tells you what's true. It shows you the move, with the exact evidence, so you start catching it yourself.

Try it — testing phase

Paste an article, see what gets flagged

Checked against all 32 patterns above. Mechanical flags are direct structural comparisons; judgment flags are candidates, not verdicts — check the quotes yourself either way.

or paste the text directly

The 32 Patterns

32 patterns
01

Attacking the Wrong Target

The rebuttal is true, but it isn't answering the claim that was actually made.

wrong assumption01

Fact-checking the wrong assumption

The response debunks the weakest, most literal reading of a claim, then treats that as having addressed the substantive point.

Example: "printing money" answered as a literal-banknotes claim, never as deficit spending financed via central-bank bond purchases.

Addresses the literal wording, not the substantive claim.
non-answer03

Non-answer fact

A true, verifiable fact is offered as if it resolves a different question than the one actually asked.

Example: "inflation was global" doesn’t address whether a country’s own policy added to its own inflation on top of global factors.

Functions as a non-sequitur relative to what was actually asked.
exaggeration04

Debunking the exaggerated version

A claim stated with hyperbole or a stereotype gets debunked at its most extreme reading, and that's treated as debunking the underlying pattern too.

Example: "that’s a stereotype" answers the overstatement, while the actual frequency of the underlying pattern is never examined.

Debunks the overstated version, not the pattern it's pointing at.
magnitude09

Magnitude as truth-value

Disputing how widespread something is functions as an answer to whether it happens at all — without addressing the other reported instances.

Example: "not widespread" used to answer "does this happen," while independent reports from unconnected locations go unaddressed.

A scope claim standing in for an existence claim.
anecdote20

Cherry-picked anecdote as representative

The mirror of magnitude-as-truth-value: one dramatic, atypical case is presented as if it represents a whole category, with no base rate given either way.

Example: a single extreme incident cited as proof of a widespread trend, with no data on how common it actually is.

Implies a pattern is common using one case chosen for its drama, not its typicality.
02

Sourcing & Verification

Where a claim actually comes from, and whether that's disclosed.

citogenesis06

Citogenesis / churnalism

An outlet's claim traces back only to other outlets repeating each other, with no primary source — document, quote, record — ever reached at the root.

Example: outlet A cites outlet B, which cites outlet C, which turns out to be citing outlet A.

The citation chain functions as repetition, not verification.
unnamed source11

Single anonymous source, multi-source confidence

A claim resting on one unnamed source is delivered with the same tone of certainty as an independently corroborated one.

Example: "sources familiar with the matter" carrying a central claim, with no second, independent source ever named.

One unverifiable voice, presented with the confidence of corroboration.
undisclosed funding25

Undisclosed funding for "independent" experts

A quoted expert or think tank is funded by the industry, company, or political actor the story concerns, without that relationship disclosed.

Example: an "independent analyst" quoted on a policy, funded by the exact side that benefits from it.

A funded voice presented as a neutral one.
state-funded26

Public funding, unstated independence assumption

Applies evenly to every publicly or state-funded outlet — BBC, CBC, NPR, PBS, RT, CGTN, Voice of America, Al Jazeera, DW — regardless of which currently reports well.

Example: coverage citing a state-funded broadcaster without noting who funds it — true of outlets across every alignment.

Funding source carries an editorial-independence question the coverage doesn't disclose either way.
AI flooding28

AI-targeted content flooding

Large volumes of content, engineered by structure and sheer volume rather than for human readership, are published specifically to be scraped into AI training or retrieval data.

Example: a network publishing millions of articles never meant for human readers, later repeated as fact by AI chatbots roughly a third of the time in independent audits; separately, a documented multi-million-dollar campaign built sites styled as independent sources to shape chatbot answers on a live conflict.

Volume and structure target a machine reader, laundering the narrative through the model's own voice.
03

Timing & Correction

When a claim lands, and whether the correction ever catches up.

silent fix12

Silent correction

A fast, wrong story is quietly edited or updated later with no notice, while the version already shared is the one everyone saw.

Example: a headline changed days later with no correction notice, while the original screenshot is still circulating.

The correction functions as record-keeping, not as reaching the audience that saw the error.
asymmetric reach13

Asymmetric prominence

The original claim gets full amplification and repetition by other outlets before it's verified; the correction, days later, gets a fraction of that reach.

Example: a front-page claim, a correction buried and unlinked from the original.

Public impression is set by exposure, not by accuracy.
deadline14

Deadline-locked timing

A claim lands before an irreversible decision point — an election, a vote, a verdict. Any correction afterward cannot undo the decision already made.

Example: a story suppressed or amplified in the days before a vote, corrected only after the vote closes.

Timing past the deadline makes accuracy structurally irrelevant to the decision it could have changed.
shock claim31

Severe claim stated as fact ahead of verification

A severe, alarming claim — an atrocity, a deliberate attack on civilians — is reported as settled fact before independent verification exists, often reinforced with emotionally intense imagery. The emotional reaction lands before any check on the claim does, and a later correction (see “deadline” and “asymmetric reach” above) doesn’t undo an emotional reaction someone’s already had.

Example: a specific atrocity claim reported as fact the same day, with no named source or independent confirmation, alongside a genuinely distressing photo.

This states a severe claim as settled before verification exists, so the emotional reaction arrives before any check on the claim does.
04

Language & Framing

The words chosen instead of the argument made.

unprovable intent07

"Lied" asserted as fact

Lying requires provable intent — knowing something is false and saying it anyway — not just being wrong or disputed. "Lied about X" stated in the outlet’s own narrative voice skips that proof.

Example: a headline stating someone "lied," when the claim is disputed or simply incorrect, not shown to be knowingly false.

Asserts a mental state as fact, not an observable fact.
redefinition15

Persuasive definition

A term's meaning is redefined so a contested question gets settled by the definition itself, while the word keeps its original emotional charge.

Example: a law restricting mandatory union agreements, named for the positive right it claims to protect rather than what it restricts.

Settles a contested question by definition, not by argument.
taboo framing16

Disagreement made taboo

The claim is protected not by evidence surviving scrutiny, but by making its negation costly to say out loud.

Example: a label chosen for its association with a historical atrocity, applied to policy skeptics on an unrelated question.

This phrase's function is disqualification, not rebuttal.
label inflation17

Severity label inflation

An extremity label is applied to a position that's simply on one side of center from the labeler's own frame.

Example: "extremist" applied to a mainstream position that merely disagrees with the outlet’s own frame.

Pre-loads a fringe verdict rather than describing a difference of position.
double standard18

Double standard

The same underlying situation gets a different label depending on which side is being described.

Example: a leader without a current election called one term in one country's coverage, a different term in a structurally identical case elsewhere.

The label is inconsistent with the facts, not derived from them.
subject-switch19

Regime-label vs. nation-label switching

Choosing between the ruling party's name and the country's name controls who's implicated — the government specifically, or the whole population.

Example: the same action described as done by "the regime" in one case and "the country" in a comparable one.

The choice of subject controls who's implicated, not what happened.
register27

Technical vs. plain register

The identical mechanism gets a clinical, expert-sounding name or a plain, alarming one, depending on who’s speaking and what they want the reader to feel.

Example: "quantitative easing" and "printing money" describe the same central-bank action; one register reads as neutral policy, the other as alarming.

Register changes how the mechanism feels, not what it is.
detail emphasis32

Most emotionally potent detail leads

Among several equally accurate ways to describe the same event, the single most emotionally resonant detail is foregrounded ahead of a more general, equally true description — shaping emotional impact independent of whether either description is accurate.

Example: "killing a 14-year-old boy and injuring several others" instead of "killing several people," when both are equally true — the child’s age leads.

This leads with the single most emotionally resonant detail rather than a general, equally accurate description.
05

Numbers & Evidence

Real data, framed to produce a feeling rather than to inform.

moving bar10

Impossible or moving evidentiary bar

"No evidence of X" conflates "hasn’t cleared this specific threshold" with "false" — and the threshold is sometimes set, or kept moving, so it can never be cleared.

Example: a standard of proof restated each time existing evidence approaches it, so the claim stays permanently "unproven."

Absence of proof beyond an unreachable bar functions as permanent disproof.
causation21

Correlation headlined as causation

A study’s "X is linked to Y" finding becomes "X causes Y" by the time it reaches the headline.

Example: "Study shows X causes Y" atop a paper that only ever measured correlation.

The headline claims a stronger relationship than the study established.
poll wording22

Leading poll-question wording

A survey question is phrased to produce the desired answer, and the resulting number is reported as neutral public opinion without the question text disclosed.

Example: a "most people believe X" statistic, with the actual question wording never printed alongside it.

The question shaped the answer before anyone was measured.
stat framing24

Relative vs. absolute risk

The same underlying numbers get reported as whichever ratio produces the desired emotional scale — a dramatic relative percentage, or a reassuring tiny absolute one.

Example: risk cut from 2-in-1,000 to 1-in-1,000 reported as "50% safer" rather than "0.1 percentage points safer" — both true, same data.

Same data, framing chosen for effect, not for informativeness.
no baseline29

Figure without its comparison baseline

A raw number — dollars, headcount, article count — is reported with no comparison baseline: no rate of change over time, and no sense of what’s typical for the specific group being cited. Without either, a lay reader has no reference point to judge the scale.

Example: a farmer’s $91,000 fuel bill reported alone tells a reader nothing — they have no idea what a farm normally spends on diesel, unlike their own experience filling up a car once a month.

The number’s weight comes from a baseline the reader supplies themselves, not one the article provides — and most readers can’t supply one for a group whose normal costs they don’t know.
one-sided30

One-sided coverage of a mutual relationship

The article covers one direction of a situation that’s inherently two-directional — both sides of a conflict, dispute, or exchange — without addressing the other side’s corresponding actions, even briefly. No specific counter-figure is needed to notice the gap; the imbalance itself is the tell.

Example: an article on one side’s strikes in an ongoing exchange of strikes, with no mention that the other side is doing the same thing around the same time.

This covers one direction of a two-way relationship as if it were the whole picture.
06

Distribution & Presentation

The layer most people actually see — headline, image, byline — versus what's underneath it.

consensus02

Consensus ≠ truth

"Most experts believe X" is cited as if it settles the matter, without engaging the specific dissenting argument actually being made.

Example: a majority-view citation used to close a debate, with the minority position’s actual reasoning never addressed.

Cites how many people agree — social weight, not evidence the claim is correct.
headline gap05

Headline mismatch

The headline makes a stronger or different claim than the article body actually supports — the layer that's most shared and least read.

Example: a headline stating something as settled that the body itself hedges, disputes, or never mentions again.

The headline claims more than the body underneath it establishes.
unverified consensus08

Weasel-worded collective will

"[Group] want/believe X" is stated as fact for a large, diffuse, unmeasured population, with no poll or survey behind it. Doesn’t apply to a small number of specific, identified parties (e.g., “the two sides” in a bilateral meeting) stating their own agreed position — no poll is needed when the parties speaking for themselves are the entire population being described.

Example: "Canadians want more of X" printed with no citation, on a question where actual polling often runs the other way.

An unmeasured, diffuse group's will is asserted as settled fact — different from two named parties describing their own agreement.
image mismatch23

Misleading image or video pairing

An old, unrelated, or out-of-context image runs alongside a story, implying it's from the current event, without a single sentence in the text being false.

Example: file footage from a different year or location run under a current-events headline with no date or location caption.

The image implies a connection the text never actually claims.

What's actually buildable

Sourcing, Timing, and Numbers mostly reduce to a structural comparison between two texts or two numbers — checkable by anyone, low room for any single model's own bias to leak in. Language & Framing, and parts of Attacking the Wrong Target, need real interpretive judgment, which is exactly where a model's own training leaves fingerprints — so the honest design there is to surface the candidate pattern and its evidence, never a verdict.